Car Hire vs Uber/Lyft in Orlando

When you’re planning your dream holiday to Orlando, one big question always comes up: should you hire a car or rely on Uber or Lyft to get around? While both options have their benefits, the best choice depends on how you’re spending your days – and who you’re travelling with.

Here’s a helpful comparison of both – with a few insider tips from us here at Debbie’s Villas.

Flexibility – Go Where the Magic Takes You

Car Hire: You’re on your schedule. Whether you’re heading off early to beat the queues at Magic Kingdom, popping out in the evening to the outlets, or making a last-minute detour to a mini golf course, having your own car means total freedom. No waiting around – just hop in and go.

Uber / Lyft: Fine for pre-planned theme park visits or meals out, but not ideal for spontaneous supermarket trips, early starts or late finishes.

Parking – Worth Considering

Car Hire: Parking at theme parks can be quite costly, with daily rates often around $30. On the bright side, hiring a car gives you the freedom to travel on your own schedule with no waiting around. Just go whenever you're ready.

Uber / Lyft: You’ll be dropped off right at the entrance—no need to worry about parking or making the long trek across a busy car park after a full day on your feet. Just keep in mind, during peak hours, you might have to wait a while for your ride back to your villa.

Convenience – Who’s Behind the Wheel?

Car Hire: Perfect if you want to explore more than just the theme parks. From day trips to the coast, to bargain-hunting at outlet malls, having a car makes it all possible and most come with built in sat-navs to make your travelling easier.

Uber / Lyft: Perfect for anyone who isn’t comfortable driving in the U.S. or simply prefers to sit back and relax—no need to navigate unfamiliar roads or fuss around with a sat nav.

Cost – Think About Group Size and Travel Plans

Car Hire: Often better value for families or larger groups, especially when sharing fuel, tolls and rental costs. Plus, it can often be bundled into your holiday booking.

Uber / Lyft: Beneficial for couples or small groups doing fewer trips – but beware of surge pricing at peak times like park closing hours. You may also need to pay more for UberXL if you’ve got lots of people or luggage.

Group Size – One Size Doesn’t Fit All

Car Hire: You can choose the right car for your group – whether you need boot space for buggies, suitcases or shopping bags.

Uber / Lyft: Larger vehicles are available, but may involve waiting longer and paying more – particularly during busy times.

Local Travel – It’s Not All About the Parks

Car Hire: Perfect for getting to supermarkets, local restaurants and lesser-known attractions. You’ll appreciate the convenience of being able to nip out whenever you like.

Uber / Lyft: You can do all of this with Uber/Lyft – but you might face longer waits, especially if you're staying in quieter villa communities.

Driving Confidence – Ready for the Roads?

Car Hire: Driving in the US does take a little adjustment, but Orlando roads are wide, well-signposted and generally easy to navigate. Almost a million Brits do it every year with no problem at all.

Uber / Lyft: If you’d rather not tackle American roads, this is a great option. Just sit back and enjoy the ride.

Availability – Be in Control

Car Hire: Your car is always ready when you are. No need to worry about availability or timings.

Uber / Lyft: Usually reliable, but driver availability can be limited late at night, during peak park exit times, or in more residential villa areas.

Our Verdict: What’s Best for Your Orlando Holiday?

Here’s what we usually suggest: • Travelling as a family or in a group? Car hire gives you more flexibility and often works out cheaper per person. • Just the two of you or mainly visiting the parks? Uber or Lyft can be more convenient – no driving, no parking fees. • Want the best of both? Many of our guests do a mix – using Uber for park days and hiring a car for a few days of shopping, exploring, or heading further afield.

At Debbie’s Villas, we offer great-value car hire options to add to your villa booking – just ask us! We'll help you choose the right vehicle for your perfect Orlando adventure.